Snotlout
Posted: 07 May 2014, 15:46
Yeah I think they are cousins I mean it says so in the books. DreamWorks wouldn't change THAT much would they?
Berk's Forumvine
The largest forum for How to Train Your Dragon fans, and Berk's Grapevine members! We have discussions, games, and a charming bunch of Dragons fans.
https://forums.berksgrapevine.com/
Snotlout
https://forums.berksgrapevine.com/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=10202126
Page 2 of 2
Snotlout
Posted: 18 May 2014, 22:55
In the movie universe, I don't think so. But in the books, Stoick and Baggybum the Beer Belly are brothers, so Snotlout and Hic are cousins. Snotlout is a huuuuuuuuge meanie to Hiccup until the eleventh book, but with that I will not go deeper into.
Snotlout
Posted: 19 May 2014, 15:20
SoD's website said they were so...
I like the idea of them being related though...
I like the idea of them being related though...
Snotlout
Posted: 19 May 2014, 16:43
SoD website says so…
The old httyd website says so…
They're both made by Dreamworks...
So it's True...
The old httyd website says so…
They're both made by Dreamworks...
So it's True...
Snotlout
Posted: 25 May 2014, 04:03
I don't think so because in Thawfest apparantly the Jorgensons have always beat Hiccup's family so thy are separate
Snotlout
Posted: 15 May 2018, 15:32
Unless they say so in the third movie, I won't believe it. It was true in the books, but was never mentioned in the movies, so I'm assuming they're not related.
If Dreamworks really wants them to be related, they should have said so in the first movie. When Hiccup was introducing the other teens, he called all of them by name, with Astrid being the only one who stood out, since he practically melted at the mere sight of her. He should have said, "Oh, and there's Fishlegs, my cousin Snotlout," etc.
If Dreamworks really wants them to be related, they should have said so in the first movie. When Hiccup was introducing the other teens, he called all of them by name, with Astrid being the only one who stood out, since he practically melted at the mere sight of her. He should have said, "Oh, and there's Fishlegs, my cousin Snotlout," etc.
Snotlout
Posted: 16 May 2018, 02:02
I agree with you, Dragon, he would have mentioned that in the first movie instead of saying everyone's name separately
Re: Snotlout
Posted: 03 Jul 2022, 16:49
Honestly, I'd believe they are. Various people have said it said so on the official site, so I'm not going to argue.
Re: Snotlout
Posted: 03 Jul 2022, 17:49
I take the "they might be" route.
The Haddocks and the Jorgensons are separate clans, and as far as I know, the clans are based on the male lineage, so it's highly unlikely that Stoick and Spitelout are brothers. However, Valka could, in theory, originally be from the Jorgenson clan as Spitelout's sister. Or, Stoick could have a sister who is Snotty's mom.
There's nothing canon to disprove it, and it is a kind of neat dynamic to think about.
The Haddocks and the Jorgensons are separate clans, and as far as I know, the clans are based on the male lineage, so it's highly unlikely that Stoick and Spitelout are brothers. However, Valka could, in theory, originally be from the Jorgenson clan as Spitelout's sister. Or, Stoick could have a sister who is Snotty's mom.
There's nothing canon to disprove it, and it is a kind of neat dynamic to think about.
Re: Snotlout
Posted: 03 Jul 2022, 23:56
Honestly, Spitelout and Stoick do have a very sibling rivalry vibe (as do Snotlout and Hiccup, actually). They never explicitly mentioned it, but I still like to think of them as brothers. 
