Berk's Forumvine

This question has been niggling at me since I watched the second movie, so I'm putting it to a vote. Which gigantic, alpha-type dragon would prevail in a one-on-one fight for dominance?

Some stats for reference:
Red Death: ~510 feet long, huge fire blasts, no blind spots, club-like tail, large and powerful jaws with huge teeth, ability to fly
Bewilderbeast: >520 feet long, powerful ice blasts, long sharp tusks, thick skull, hard skin, ability to swim

Also since the Red Death can fly she has a higher opportunity for sneak attacks on the Bewilderbeast. With her flames she also has a more effective weapon against him since she can melt his skin and his breath weapon.

well the red death seemed bigger or the same size to me for some reason. I think due to the fact that the bewilderbeast breathes ice, it may not be immune to fire like the other dragons. so red death in my opinion would win

The Bewilderbeast evidently has far superior mind-control powers (the Red Death's being limited to more of a homing beacon effect), so it would just mind control the Red Death into hitting itself, presumably while making the draconic equivalent of cliched bully taunts.

Valka did make the distinction between Queen dragons and Alpha dragons. "Every nest has its queen, but the bewilderbeast is the king of all dragons" Or something to that affect. Implying that the Alpha bewilderbeast is more powerful than the Queen red death. If thats the case then it could probably be assumed that the Red Death would have to obey an alpha Bewilderbeast, or even Anyway the point is Alpha Bewilderbeast > Queen Red Death just by rank alone.

Cartoon Freak

17 Jun 2014, 14:21

The Bewilderbeast evidently has far superior mind-control powers (the Red Death's being limited to more of a homing beacon effect), so it would just mind control the Red Death into hitting itself, presumably while making the draconic equivalent of cliched bully taunts.

Oh yes

Also it's got those monstrous tusks which come in handy

The Red Death was recently added to the Dragonpedia so we can base who would win on the stats now :3

"Firepower" seems to be a very loose concept.

Faerie_Dragon

21 Jun 2014, 17:27

The Red Death was recently added to the Dragonpedia so we can base who would win on the stats now :3

Zer0x

21 Jun 2014, 17:49

"Firepower" seems to be a very loose concept.

clearly, but I still think that the Red Death would win

How about the Red Death against Drago's Bewilderbeast?